Santino asks Supreme Court not to kick her off Palm Beach County bench


Emphasizing her good works since she took the bench in January, Palm Beach County Judge Dana Santino on Monday urged the Florida Supreme Court to reject a recommendation that she be removed from office for blasting her opponent’s work as a defense attorney during her successful 2016 election campaign.

The test of whether someone should be removed from office isn’t their past transgressions, attorney Jeremy Kroll, who represents Santino, said in a 33-page brief filed with the state’s highest court. Rather, he said, it’s whether a judge is currently unfit for office.

While admitting that Santino, a former probate and guardianship attorney, erred by blasting attorney Gregg Lerman for representing “murderers, rapists, child molesters and other criminals,” he said she has apologized for her ill-advised attacks and has dedicated herself to being a fair and impartial judge.

“Despite Judge Santino’s campaign violations, the unrebutted evidence adduced of her exemplary performance as a jurist and her stellar background and character do not support a finding of present unfitness,” he wrote.

Kroll’s legal brief was filed nearly two months after a panel of the state’s Judicial Qualifications Commission recommended Santino be stripped of her judicial robe.

“Her conduct was not simply the product of an isolated instance of indiscretion, a momentary lapse of judgment; or the exposure of human frailty from which we all suffer from time to time,” Sumter County Circuit Judge Michelle Morley wrote on behalf of the six-member panel. “The conduct here was repeated, intentional, direct action with a designed purpose which cast aspersions and doubt onto the heart of the judicial system.”

In his response, Kroll recounted the praise Santino received in August from fellow judges during a hearing before the panel of the judicial watchdog group. He noted that Palm Beach County’s then Chief Judge Jeffrey Colbath, County Judge Ted Booras and other court officials credited Santino with taking steps to resolve cases quickly.

Kroll also pointed out that they said she has volunteered to oversee civil drug court on weekends and to help other judges. Booras, a former prosecutor who knew Santino when she worked as an intern in the state attorney’s office and as a probation officer, declared her “an excellent judge.”

Further, Kroll said the recommended punishment is far more severe than other judges, who have committed similar infractions, received. He cited cases of judges elsewhere in the state who have been allowed to remain on the bench even though they violated judicial canons by misrepresenting their opponents’ qualifications or inflating their own on the campaign trail.

Lerman, who filed the complaint against Santino with the watchdog group, said the punishment others received is immaterial. “So when does it stop?” he asked. “If as she told others — ‘It’s not a big deal. I’ll just pay a fine.’ — where does it stop? The carousel goes around and around and people continue to violate the rules.”

Critics have pointed out that her attacks on Lerman’s work as a defense lawyer ignored bedrock constitutional rights, such as the right to counsel and innocent until proven guilty. Similarly, the panel said Santino’s campaign strategy was an attack on the judicial system.

“Her entire campaign was inflammatory and rife with innuendo,” Morley said. “She repeatedly implied that representing persons charged with crimes was, by its very nature, dishonorable and antithetical to the public good.”

The panel will be allowed to respond to Santino’s claims. Then, the Supreme Court could elect to hear oral arguments before deciding what punishment to mete out. In the meantime, Santino remains on the county civil court bench, deciding eviction cases, landlord-tenant disputes and other lawsuits where less than $15,000 is at stake.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Have you seen him? Sheriff’s office looking for missing, endangered man
Have you seen him? Sheriff’s office looking for missing, endangered man

The Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office is asking for the public’s help in finding an 87-year-old endangered Boynton Beach man.  Joseph Bilotti was last seen around 3 p.m. Saturday driving away from his home in the 7800 block of Rinehart Drive in Boynton Beach. He was in a 2008 gray Mercedes Benz C300 (Tag# 889NZR) and has not been...
NEW: What you need to know about Art Fest on the Green in Wellington
NEW: What you need to know about Art Fest on the Green in Wellington

The Wellington Art Society’s annual two-day festival returns this month with more of the vendors and demonstrations that have made the event a favorite on the South Florida art festival circuit. The 12th annual Art Fest on the Green will be Jan. 27-28 at the Wellington Amphitheater. With a roster of local and national artists, this year&rsquo...
John Legend blames Trump for government shutdown, calls him racist
John Legend blames Trump for government shutdown, calls him racist

Grammy and Oscar-winning singer John Legend is claiming that President Donald Trump and his team’s alleged racism are behind the government shutdown. Legend, who has vocally criticized Trump Sr. and Jr. both in the past, tweeted the following just after midnight Saturday: “The reason the government shutdown is that Trump...
Three fun things happening in Lake Worth
Three fun things happening in Lake Worth

1. Art Meets Jazz on J Street Exhibition in Gallery, through Feb. 6, Clay Glass Metal Stone Gallery, 15 South J Street.Check out Jazz on J Street inspired photography, sketch art, fine and mixed media artwork. 2. Paint Your Wagon, Lake Worth Playhouse, 713, Lake Avenue. In California in May 1853, Ben Rumson strikes gold and establishes...
Hop on over to Lake Worth Beach’s Bonfire on Friday
Hop on over to Lake Worth Beach’s Bonfire on Friday

The Lake Worth Beach Bonfire started in 1997 as a low-key event, attended mostly by locals. The event has certainly changed over the years. “Now it has grown in not only size, but popularity,” said Lauren Bennett, Lake Worth’s Assistant Leisure Services Director. “Not only are we the only beach in the county that hosts bonfires...
More Stories