No deal in Jeffrey Epstein victims’ lawsuit against federal prosecutors


Wearing a black sweater, black slacks and silver handcuffs, a 28-year-old John I. Leonard High School graduate was brought into federal court by U.S. marshals on Tuesday to represent dozens of other young women who were allegedly sexually abused by Palm Beach billionaire Jeffrey Epstein.

The handcuffs, her attorney Bradley Edwards said, are the most visible signs of the ongoing trauma she suffers from being turned into a high-paid sex toy for Epstein when she was 14. Once a driven high-school student, her life spiraled out of control after being lured into prostitution by Epstein, Edwards said. Convicted of petty theft on the west coast of Florida, she is now back in jail for violating her probation.

But the handcuffs didn’t stop the woman from spending four hours negotiating with federal prosecutors in an attempt to settle the lawsuit she and another victim filed against the U.S. government for striking a deal with Epstein allowing him to escape serious federal charges. The lawsuit by Jane Does 1 and 2 alleges the government violated the victims’ rights by striking the non-prosecution agreement without first notifying them.

Epstein later served 13 months of an 18-month sentence in the Palm Beach County Stockade after he pleaded guilty to lesser state charges of soliciting a minor for prostitution and soliciting prostitution.

The case made international headlines after another victim, in a sworn statement, claimed Epstein, now 63, offered her to his powerful friends, including Britain’s Prince Andrew — an accusation he denied.

U.S. Magistrate Dave Lee Brannon, who presided over the unusual settlement talks, said no accord was reached Tuesday.

He urged the two sides to continue to negotiate. If no settlement is reached, the lawsuit, accusing the U.S. Attorney’s Office of violating the Crime Victims Rights Act, could be headed to trial.

Like virtually everything about the case, which erupted in June 2008 when federal prosecutors agreed not to prosecute Epstein as long as he pleaded guilty in state court to the two prostitution-related charges, the negotiations are shrouded in secrecy.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Ann Marie Villafana declined comment on the closed-door session. Edwards would only talk in generalities.

The decades-old crime-victims law doesn’t allow the women to receive any money. Instead, Edwards said, Jane Doe 1 and the roughly 40 victims she said she represents want an official acknowledgment that what happened to them was wrong and assurances it won’t happen to others. Edwards also indicated he wants the government to pay a fine, hopefully to be used to help crime victims.

He also said his client wants federal prosecutors to pursue Epstein for federal crimes. “She wants him in jail,” Edwards said. “Since the June 2008 plea, that’s always been her No. 1 priority. Treat him like you treat anyone else who did this.”

Edwards acknowledged progress was been made since the first negotiating session with Brannon in May. But, he said, major sticking points remain. Prosecutors, he said, disagree with his claim that Epstein’s victims should have been notified of the non-prosecution deal before it was approved.

When Epstein agreed to plead guilty to the state charges, he also agreed to pay attorneys who represented more than two-dozen underage girls who filed lawsuits or settled claims against Epstein, alleging they were lured to his Palm Beach mansion to give him sexually charged massages and/or sex in exchange for money. Jane Does 1 and 2 are among those who received confidential monetary settlements in civil cases.

The negotiating sessions have been difficult for Jane Doe 1, Edwards said. “She’s carrying a heavy weight and is thinking of a class of victims that she went to high school with and who brought her to (Epstein’s) house. She’s trying to do right by them.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Federal suit claims Palm Beach Gardens man was real estate “racketeer”
Federal suit claims Palm Beach Gardens man was real estate “racketeer”

While Tamara Filippova sat in her house in Siberia, her son-in-law in Palm Beach Gardens used her name to create a real estate world that defrauded her of more than $8 million, her lawyers say in a federal lawsuit filed this week. The 21-count, 158-page suit against Ilia Mogilevsky, which cites the federal Civil Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations...
A night at Mar-a-Lago: The blow-out bash by Trump’s booster club
A night at Mar-a-Lago: The blow-out bash by Trump’s booster club

On the eve of a potential government shutdown, hundreds of people decked out in patriotic colors shrugged off the crisis in Washington and gathered Thursday at President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate on Palm Beach to celebrate the first anniversary of his inauguration. More than 900 people attended the Red, White & Blue Celebration for...
Flu virus spread by breathing, study finds
Flu virus spread by breathing, study finds

Most people believe that the influenza virus is spread through the coughs and sneezes of infected people, but new research published Thursday suggests that the flu virus is spread more easily than previously thought. Medical professionals believe that the virus is spread most often by “droplets made when people with flu cough, sneeze or talk...
NEW: Lawyers for teen girl killed in crash appeal tossing of Lyft suit
NEW: Lawyers for teen girl killed in crash appeal tossing of Lyft suit

Lawyers for the parents of 13-year-old Karenine Saint Louis, killed in a July crash, have appealed a judge’s ruling that Lyft can’t be held responsible for driving her to a friend’s house. According to police reports and court documents, early on July 9, the honor student stuffed her bed with pillows and sneaked out of her suburban...
Brightline train accident 911 call: Cyclist didn’t stop for train
Brightline train accident 911 call: Cyclist didn’t stop for train

Two 911 calls reporting Wednesday’s fatal Brightline train accident were released Friday by Boynton Beach Police. One call is from a witness and the second is from a Florida East Coast Railway dispatcher. A northbound Brightline train struck and killed Jeffrey King, 51, at Ocean Avenue. The witness, who did not give...
More Stories