Cerabino: After Hurricane Irma, nobody asking for less government


The deaths of eight elderly residents inside a powerless South Florida nursing home are bound to become one of the stories of Hurricane Irma that will linger.

Dangerously high temperatures at the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills from the loss of air conditioning in the nursing home is believed to have led to the deaths as well as the hospitalization of 10 other residents there.

It’s not the only local nursing home that lost power during the storm without sufficient backup to keep temperatures from getting to life-threatening levels. And some are already questioning why nursing homes aren’t among the first facilities to be reconnected to power after a storm.

Gov. Rick Scott, sensing the public outcry, was quick to call the deaths “unfathomable” and promise swift and comprehensive attention.

“Every facility that is charged with caring for patients must take every action and precaution to keep their patients safe – especially patients that are in poor health,” Scott said in a prepared statement. “I have directed the Agency for Health Care Administration and the Department of Children and Families to immediately work with local law enforcement to conduct an investigation, and if they find that anyone wasn’t acting in the best interests of their patients, we will hold them accountable to the fullest extent of the law.

“I am also asking available first responders to immediately check in with the health-care facilities in their area to make sure nursing homes and assisted living facilities are able to keep their residents safe.”

What we need, he’s saying, is a bigger government involvement in protecting the health and welfare of people who may be receiving substandard care.

I am not the first person to note that while Scott was issuing his government-to-the-rescue message, White House spokeswoman Sarah Huckabee Sanders was fielding questions from reporters in Washington about whether President Donald Trump would be amenable to the government taking a bigger role in health care insurance, either by a single-payer system or one that shores up Obamacare through subsidies.

“I can’t think of anything worse than government being more involved in your health care, rather than less involved,” she said. “The president is focused on looking at ways where government gets out of the way, and people have more control over their health care.”

Government bad. Private sector good. Just keep government out of the way and everybody’s health outcomes improve in the hands of the private sector, which I guess would include privately run nursing homes.

“The most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the government and I’m here to help,” Ronald Reagan once famously said.

But no elected officials say that in the aftermath of a hurricane. Everybody, including trickle-down true believers, carries on like socialists after a big storm.

Where’s FEMA? Will the government pay for my roof? Will the government open a shelter near me? Will the government make me safe by imposing a curfew?

Will the government step in and make sure the private utility company works with the private nursing homes better so that no elderly people die from a lack of air conditioning?

I need help. Where’s my county commissioner, my state representative, my congressman, my senator?

Nobody talks about the magic of free enterprise after a hurricane.

Imagine if Gov. Scott used Sarah Huckabee Sanders’ script to respond to the nursing home deaths.

Imagine if Scott said, “Yes, those deaths are unfortunate, but the answer isn’t more government. I can’t think of anything worse than the government getting more involved in nursing home residents’ health care. We need to let the private sector work without burdensome jobs-killing governmental regulation and just let the nursing home patients be in charge of their own health care.”

No, what you saw instead was a call for multiple government agencies to respond. And for government to step in and do what it takes to make sure something like this doesn’t happen again.

And in the end, it will probably result in state legislation that imposes new regulations on nursing homes or utility companies.

As it turns out, it’s not burdensome regulation when it’s your grandmother.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Actors take the stage at area libraries

Shakespeare was right when he observed, “All the world’s a stage.” This week, the stage comes to three area libraries, as players strut their stuff for the entertainment of theater lovers. On Monday, the Script-in-Hand Players presents “Encounters,” three plays about chance meetings with humorous results. The program begins...
Saint Joseph’s Episcopal School hosts annual Back to School BBQ
Saint Joseph’s Episcopal School hosts annual Back to School BBQ

SOUTH TECH ACADEMY An open house begins at 6:30 p.m. Nov. 1 at the tuition-free charter school, 1300 SW 30th Ave., Boynton Beach. School staff will be on hand to provide information on academic and student support services, clubs and organizations. Admissions assistance will be available. Career academies include medical sciences, veterinary assisting...
North blotter: Fired employee fails to win back job after cursing at manager
North blotter: Fired employee fails to win back job after cursing at manager

PALM BEACH GARDENS POLICE ASSAULT Upset over being fired, a man returned to his previous place of employment in the 3800 block of Northlake Boulevard to confront the manager who terminated him. Though seeking his job back, the man began cursing at the manager. He was being escorted out of the store when he quickly turned around as if he were going...
South blotter: Officer finds over 2,000 grams of marijuana during traffic stop
South blotter: Officer finds over 2,000 grams of marijuana during traffic stop

BOYNTON BEACH POLICE DRUGS During a traffic stop on a vehicle in the 1000 block of Miner Road, police found 2,842 grams of pot. Given the large size of the haul, police determined that the driver and passenger were both aware of their cargo. The two men were arrested and taken to the county jail. The driver was found with $656, which was seized for...
New library opens Tuesday in Port St. Lucie
New library opens Tuesday in Port St. Lucie

Celebrate the opening of the first new library facility in St. Lucie County in almost two decades. The ribbon-cutting ceremony and open house take place 10:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. Tuesday at the Paula A. Lewis Branch Library, 2950 SW Rosser Blvd. in Port St. Lucie. The former Port St. Lucie Police substation has been transformed into a 21,000-square-foot...
More Stories