Port of Palm Beach sued by contractor over Caribbean, Cuba berth cost

The Port of Palm Beach Commission and its executive director Manuel Almira are scheduled to hold a closed-door strategy session with the port attorneys Thursday over a lawsuit a contractor has filed against the port over its Berth 17 project.

Berth 17, a mini-slip at the Riviera Beach-based port’s southernmost berth, has been touted as an expansion and infrastructure improvement that will serve as a base for rail-barge service for the entire Caribbean and potentially, for cargo service to Cuba. The slip will allow the port to add another user and will feature daily loading and unloading of cargo via roll-on/roll-off ramp.

RELATED: Gov. Scott includes “no Cuba trade” edict for ports

LM Heavy Civil Construction, Palm Beach Gardens has sued the port seeking at least an additional $376,669 because the deteriorating steel sheet piles could not be removed using standard methods. The total amount in dispute is $618,006.

Port attorney Donald Bicknell declined comment.


The $11.3 million Berth 17 and paving project broke ground in July 2016 and was slated to be completed this month. The project is now expected to be completed by December.

The total included $10.4 million in construction costs and $897,000 in engineering fees. Additional engineering fees of $187,973 are being paid to the project’s engineering firm, AECOM Technical Services, West Palm Beach.

Difficulties in removing crumbling sheet metal piles along with additional engineering costs have increased the project’s price tag and lengthened the construction time, according to a report by Port Engineer Jose Soler.

If all the additional claims are granted, the cost could reach $12.1 million.

READ ALSO: JFK Peanut Island bunker could be taken over by Palm Beach County

AECOM, which oversees the project, has denied LMH’s request for additional cost and time, and advised the port that under the contract, the contractor is responsible for removing the piles, Soler’s report states.

The plans LMH was provided stated the existing 63-year-old sheet piles were in poor condition, but mandated the piles could be removed by pulling.

“However, LMH discovered that the existing sheet piles could not be pulled utilizing standard means and methods, because, among other things, they were so deteriorated and decrepit that attempts to pull the sheet piles disintegrated them to such a degree that they could not be removed by pulling,” the lawsuit states.

Because the conditions LMH encountered were substantially different from what the port had indicated and/or what is typically encountered in the general location of the project, LMH encountered delays and substantial unforeseen costs. It had to construct a dam and excavate below the surface of the water to remove the sheet piles, according to the lawsuit.

It took 37 days to remove the sheet piles instead of the two days originally projected.

Berth 17 is the latest of a number of large projects the 162-acre port has completed in the last 17 years.

Since 2000, the port added the $30 million “Skypass” bridge, a $15 million cruise terminal and a $15 million maritime office complex. It also opened a South Gate Entrance, along with a 40,000-square-foot warehouse and a four-acre cargo transfer terminal.

In 2014, the port completed a $26 million restoration and expansion of Slip No. 3. The project, funded primarily by the Florida Department of Transportation, included replacing sheet pile that had been in place since 1954.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in

Equifax apologizes for sending people to fake company website
Equifax apologizes for sending people to fake company website

Equifax linked people to a fake online site that mimicked the link for its own site on its massive Sept. 7 security breach that affected 143 million Americans. After the breach, which involved Social Security numbers and other key identifying information, Equifax set up a site, equifaxsecurity2017.com, that directed people to information on the...
Death Wish coffee recalled over botulism concerns
Death Wish coffee recalled over botulism concerns

Death Wish Coffee Company, a New York-based coffee producer that advertises itself as maker of the “world’s strongest coffee,” is recalling some of its products over concerns that it could become tainted with the deadly botulin toxin. Officials with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration said in a notice issued Tuesday that 11-ounce...
After Irma: Consumers face new reality with higher storm deductibles
After Irma: Consumers face new reality with higher storm deductibles

Floridians have filed close to half a million property insurance claims worth an estimated $3 billion in the two weeks after Hurricane Irma hit, but more than 17,000 claims already have been closed without payment, records show — and consumers like John Flynn of Lake Worth find themselves wrestling with a bigger financial burden than they hoped...
More free time, less effort: 9 ways to be more productive at work
More free time, less effort: 9 ways to be more productive at work

Anyone who's ever held gainful employment at any level knows what it's like to goof off on the job. You text your best friend, skip out to get another latte or vending machine snack, veer from a meeting into a gossip session and, suddenly, where has the day gone?Not only do most of us excel at wasting time, just 17 percent of people can accurately...
Lake Worth warehouses fetch nearly $31 million
Lake Worth warehouses fetch nearly $31 million

Two warehouses that are part of an industrial building boom in Palm Beach County just sold for $30.7 million. The Silverman Group is the new owner of the 252,000-square-foot Interstate Business Center at 701 Boutwell Road in Lake Worth. The buildings were completed in 2016. Robert Smith, Jeff Kelly and Kirk Nelson of CBRE handled the sale. The buildings...
More Stories