breaking news

Secret Service: Lantana air rules tough, but needed to protect Trump

End of ‘frivolous’ lawsuits? Local businesses see tort cases rise


Is America’s litigious streak ebbing?

Tort lawsuits have been headline news ever since a grandma spilled a cup of coffee on herself and won a million dollar-plus lawsuit. They’ve also been the bane of businesses decrying “frivolous” complaints for raising their legal expenses — and the cost to consumers.

Palm Beach Tech strives to connect tech entrepreneurs, start-ups

I’ve seen it all in my years as a journalist, including a group that sued gentlemen’s clubs for failing to adhere to Americans with Disabilities Act compliance. And, yes, I’ve reported on personal injury lawsuits that were legitimate, and the punitive and economic damages reasonable and necessary to address the consequences.

But a Wall Street Journal story, citing data compiled by the National Center for State Courts, could signal relief to businesses.

Maybe.

How businessmen in Jupiter, WPB, Lake Worth learned from failure

The Journal reports that tort cases (primarily auto, medical malpractice and product liability cases) declined from 16 percent of civil filings in state courts in 1993 to about 4 percent in 2015, “a difference of more than 1.7 million cases nationwide, while contract disputes rose from 18 percent of the civil docket to 51 percent during that period.”

The opposite has been true in Palm Beach County, however. Over the past decade, case filing stats provided by Malarie Dauginikas and the staff at the Office of the Clerk & Comptroller show a sharp rise in the number of tort cases filed in the county. In 2016, the number of tort cases filed — 3,976 — was 700 cases higher than in 2007.

One attorney, Irwin Gilbert, says don’t expect a drop-off.

Gilbert, a partner in the law firm Kelley Kronenberg’s West Palm Beach office, pointed to a case in which he is defending a security company being sued by a resident in a gated condo community.

The resident, Gilbert explained, is being foreclosed on and he is suing the security company for “hurting his feelings” when the security company’s guards directed the resident to the visitor’s entrance rather than the one for residents.

“You can’t make this stuff up,” he said. “We have one silly case after another.”

If there has been a drop-off in business-related litigation, Gilbert said, it is in the B2B lawsuit category. And he said that change has more to do with money than law.

“What I have observed is a change in culture that reflects is a tremendous sensitivity now to cost and expense,” said Gilbert.

Companies are taking a harder look at the cost-benefit analysis to decipher whether to spend the funds on litigation rather than conceding the loss as a lesson learned.

“Companies have been forced to take a more conservative view,” he said. “They are taking a second and third look before deciding to pull the trigger.”

Gilbert said companies will still sue to, say, keep a former employee from breaking a non-compete clause or to protect a trademark or trade secret.

But in cases where a company is owed money, he said companies are “asking more sophisticated questions, and many more questions, about how the litigation could disrupt their business, how long will it go on and whether the amount owed is really recoverable by litigation.”

Good points to consider before suing, period.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in

South Florida among ‘overvalued’ housing markets to make Amazon cut
South Florida among ‘overvalued’ housing markets to make Amazon cut

As Amazon decides which of 20 metro areas to name the home of its second headquarters, how heavily will it weigh housing costs? That’s an open question, but the ecommerce giant seems not to be turned off by frothy housing markets. More than half of the 20 finalists — including South Florida — have home prices that are “overvalued...
Kroger looking to partner with Overstock.com: report
Kroger looking to partner with Overstock.com: report

Kroger is considering teaming up with Overstock.com Inc. in an effort to compete with online retailers. The New York Post reported the Cincinnati-based grocer may be eyeing a deal with Overstock.com, according to sources. Overstock CEO Patrick Byrne said last year that he plans to sell or reorganize the e-commerce business to focus on blockchain...
No better than 94th? We second-guess the Swanepoel 200
No better than 94th? We second-guess the Swanepoel 200

The widely watched Swanepoel Power 200 list of the most important people in the residential real estate industry came out this week, and Floridians seemed to get short shrift. The highest-ranked Florida player on the list is Michael Saunders, head of a Sarasota brokerage, who placed 94th. Not that we’d ever nitpick, but it’s noteworthy...
Brightline asks opponents for help with safety campaign
Brightline asks opponents for help with safety campaign

All Aboard Florida’s Brightline on Tuesday called on its opponents who have been fighting to block the passenger service to help spread its safety message following recent deaths involving the private rail venture’s trains. In a letter to the chairman of Citizens Against Rail Expansion in Florida, Brightline’s President and Chief...
Palm Beach County office market: Rising rents, falling vacancy
Palm Beach County office market: Rising rents, falling vacancy

In Palm Beach County’s office market, rents are rising, vacancy rates are falling and new construction remains scarce. That’s according to a year-end market report by commercial real estate brokerage Avison Young. It finds the average rent for the county’s office space was $33.43 in 2017, up sharply from $30.19 in 2016. The vacancy...
More Stories