Battle royal continues over Palm Beach mansion


The standoff between Russia and the United States over the Ukraine isn’t the only source of tension between the two superpowers. In a Palm Beach County courtroom, the battle over a Palm Beach mansion sold to Russian oligarch Dmitri Rybolovlev has erupted into a recent flurry of bitter filings by lawyers for Dmitri and his estranged wife, Elena.

The filings demand sanctions against attorneys on both sides, following a contentious London deposition of Dmitri last August. The deposition was over a lawsuit Elena brought against Dmitri involving his 2008 purchase, through a company, of a Palm Beach mansion owned by real estate mogul Donald Trump.

The Palm Beach Post was the first to report the sale and price: $95 million.

The 33,000-square-foot mansion at 515 N. County Rd., dubbed Maison de L’Amitie, formerly was owned by the late health care magnate Abe Gosman. Trump bought the property out of Gosman’s bankruptcy.

With the Rybolovlev couple is in the midst of a divorce in a Swiss court, Elena is trying to pin down marital assets spread across the globe. Dmitri is fighting efforts to have a Swiss asset freeze apply to jurisdictions outside of Switzerland — including Florida.

Relations between the couple are deteriorating. Last month, Elena made international headlines when it was reported she was arrested in Cypress on charges she took a diamond ring that belongs to a Dmitri family trust fund.

But David Newman, a lawyer for Elena, said the arrest was made in error. Elena owns the ring, he said. Newman, of the Day Pitney law firm in New York, provided an invoice to this columnist, showing that the 15.4 carat pink, pear-shape diamond ring was purchased by Elena for $26 million (including tax) in March 2008 at Graff, a high-end London jeweler.

Big money defines the Rybolovlev couple. In Forbes’ 2014 rankings of the world’s billionaires, Rybolovlev comes in at No. 147, worth $8.8 billion. He formerly owned a large stake in Uralkali, a fertilizer company.

After news broke of the $95 million Palm Beach mansion sale, Rybolovlev told the Wall Street Journal that the Trump “acquisition is simply an investment in real estate by one of the companies in which I have an interest.”

In 2009, Elena sued Dmitri in Palm Beach County Circuit Court to protect the Palm Beach estate, claiming her husband “has a history of secreting and transferring assets in order to avoid his obligations.”

Subsequently, in Palm Beach County Circuit Court filings, Dmitri said he did not own the property, “either directly or indirectly.” He told French journalists the property was in trust “to secure the future of our two daughters.”

The bad feelings between Elena and Dmitri now have spilled over to their lawyers.

Newman acknowledged that relations between him and Dmitri’s West Palm Beach lawyer, John Christiansen, have become nearly as chilled as the U.S. and Russia over Crimea.

“I’m not sending troops down to (Christiansen’s house), but they are frosty, yes,” Newman said in an interview last week.

Here’s why.

Newman wants to depose Dmitri again because he claims Dmitri was uncooperative during last year’s deposition. In court filings, Newman said Dmitri stated, “I have already answered this question,” or variations on that theme, 120 times.

In fact, Newman was so incensed by the deposition that he filed papers to sanction both Christiansen and Dmitri for “outrageous and obstructionist” conduct, ranging from allegations of prompting from handwritten notes, to non-answers to frivolous objections.

“It is plain and simple law of Florida that a witness cannot refuse to answer a question because it has allegedly already been asked and answered,” Newman wrote in his filing.

Meanwhile, Christiansen has his own beef with Newman.

In a motion for sanctions against Newman, Christiansen said the videographer used at the deposition wrongly zeroed in on handwritten notes by Dmitri’s Swiss lawyer, Tetiana Bersheda. Christiansen said the notes are privileged, and Newman’s instructions to have the videographer zoom in on the notes “are inappropriate and unethical.”

A hearing was held Feb. 28 in Palm Beach County Circuit Court to determine whether another Dmitri deposition should be held. ” The court has not yet ruled on the motions at hand, but my client and I are fully confident in the position we have taken in the matter,” Christiansen said.

In court filings, Christiansen argued against another deposition of Dmitri, especially since the August one “far exceeded the limited scope” of the lawsuit…Any further deposition would be beating a dead horse.” He also points to various excerpts from the deposition showing Dmitri answered Newman’s questions.

Additionally, Christiansen reiterated Dmitri has no interest or control of the trust or LLC affiliated with 515 N. County Road.

So far, Dmitri is winning the legal wars.

Last month, Dmitri won a lawsuit in Hawaii, with Elena losing her bid to include a $20 million property as part of their marital assets. The order states that a Swiss court’s order to freeze the couple’s marital assets cannot be enforced in Hawaii. Newman said Elena plans an appeal.

Alexandra Clough writes about the economy, real estate and the law. Contact her at aclough@pbpost.com.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation & World

California wildfires: Why you shouldn’t intervene with wildlife
California wildfires: Why you shouldn’t intervene with wildlife

Days after a video of a man appearing to rescue a wild rabbit from California wildfire flames made headlines, numerous experts are saying his actions weren’t a good idea. Video taken Dec. 7 in La Conchita, California, showed an unidentified man dressed in shorts and a hoodie corralling a wild rabbit  along Highway 1.  California...
Mother says she was kicked off flight for breastfeeding son
Mother says she was kicked off flight for breastfeeding son

A mother, her children and elderly parents, were kicked off a Spirit Airlines flight Friday for refusing to listen to crew instructions, the airline said.  However, Mei Rui, an acclaimed pianist and cancer researcher, tells it differently, according to KHOU. She was on a flight from Houston to Newark, New Jersey, to attend a recording as...
Trump accusers call for congressional investigation into alleged sexual misconduct
Trump accusers call for congressional investigation into alleged sexual misconduct

Update 3:15 p.m. Dec. 11: White House press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders denied the allegations levied against President Donald Trump in a news briefing Monday, telling reporters that the president has “addressed these accusations directly and denied all of these allegations.” "The American people knew this and voted...
Woman arrested, accused of threatening to ‘kill everybody’ on Southwest flight
Woman arrested, accused of threatening to ‘kill everybody’ on Southwest flight

A woman was arrested after she was accused of smoking on a plane and threatening to kill passengers on the flight. KOIN reported that the woman was on a Southwest Airlines flight from Portland, Oregon to Sacramento, California,  Saturday. Passenger-recorded video appears to show a woman yelling at crew. “I swear if you don’t (expletive)...
‘Welcome to Florida’ sign covered in snow
‘Welcome to Florida’ sign covered in snow

Visitors to the Sunshine State got a winter’s greeting when the “Welcome to Florida” sign was seen blanketed in snow.  The image of the snowy welcome sign was shared by news website northescambia.com. The state, as well as much of the Deep South, was hit by uncharacteristic cold over the weekend, which dropped flurries and left...
More Stories